KGET Community

Welcome to KGET Community Sign in | Join | Help
in
back to KGET.com Home Blogs Forums Photos Calendar

Kiyoshi Tomono's Blog

Men considering legal action in Oildale arrest

Xavier Zamora says he's an amateur moviemaker.    

 Which is why the 23-year-old grabbed a video camera when he heard a commotion outside his Oildale home last month.

     What he caught on camera was a 3-minute struggle between five Bakersfield police officers and a fleeing felon.

     Zamora's actions and, officers say, his refusal to stay a safe distance from the confrontation, landed him in jail.

     Both Zamora and the man captured in the video, 25-year-old Leonard Marella, say they are considering legal action against the police department.

 

Officers Search

     Officers say they were in Oildale searching for a home invasion robber who broke into a home, beat an elderly man with an ax handle and fled after stealing the man's handgun.

     When officers approached Leonard Marella March 11, he ran.

     Marella admits he's a former gang member.  He shows areas on his neck and arms where he says he had gang tattoos removed.

     He is no stranger to the court system.

     Murder charges against him were dropped in the jailhouse beating death of a murder suspect in the Amanda Zubia murder case.

     Marella also has drug and alcohol charges.

     On that March afternoon, Marella admits he was concealing drugs. That's why he says he ran when the officers approached.

     The chase took Marella and officers through front and back yards.  At one point, Marella ran inside a home and offered the residents $300 to help hide him.

     There weren't any takers.

     As he left the house, he says he did so with his hands up, ready to surrender peacefully to police.

 

Another Side

     Officers tell another tale.  They say Marella resisted arrest and was combative.  They say he refused to show them his hands, so they could be certain he was unarmed.

     "You had several occasions where he fell to the ground during the pursuit, he gets up and runs away despite office telling him not to," said Sgt. Greg Terry, a spokesman with the Bakersfield Police Department. "When he goes to the ground he has his hands and arms concealed under his body, he refuses to put them out.  Despite the Taser being deployed, he refuses to comply with their orders."    

     The Taser barb struck Marella near his right ear.

     "They said down, and that's all I remember,’’ Marella said. “I heard the shot (from the Taser gun) and it was done."

     Officers say after the Taser, they used baton strikes to get Marella to show his hands.  When that failed, they say they deployed the police dog that bit Marella's leg.

     "There's no need,’’ Marella said. “They are supposed to do justice. They shot me in the face you know, that was enough, I was down.  I was out, I was unconscious."

     "To do all this extra, maybe they were upset from running, or maybe because I took them on a chase, it's not necessary," he added.

 

The cameraman

     There was another arrest that day.

      Xavier Zamora, 23, was behind the camera, and he was pretty close to the struggle between Zamora and the officers.

      Officer Anthony Hernandez told Zamora to get back.  In the video he shot, Zamora appears to step back for about 30 seconds, then moves in for a closer shot.

     In the video, Hernandez barks: "Would you get back ... I said get back ... wait over there."

     As Zamora retreats, Officer Stephen Kaufman approaches him.

     "I'll be taking that," Kaufman tells Zamora, apparently referring to the videocamera.

     "It's my First Amendment right,” Zamora says, “I'm with an entertainment company ... I've got lawyers," Zamora told the officer.

     On Monday, in an interview with 17News, Zamora said, "I was arrested for filming and charged with resisting arrest, obstruction of justice and delaying a peace officer … and in the tape, you can see that didn't happen … I thought it was freedom of the press to film whatever I wanted to film.’’

     Again, Terry says you have to understand the situation from the officer's point of view.

     "You have a foot pursuit, you have a guy actively resisting and possibly armed and they're trying to get him into custody," Sgt. Terry said.

     "Then have another individual run up, regardless of what his intentions were, an officer had to turn his intentions to him and instruct him to back up."

     Zamora was charged with felony possession of stolen property because his mother reported the video camera stolen.

     Zamora's mother says her son moved out on bad circumstances and she filed the report to teach her son a lesson. She says intends to drop the charges.

      The obstruction of justice charge against Zamora was dismissed.

      Marella pleaded no contest to drug possession and gun charges and will go to prison for about three years and eight months.

      Officers say he was armed and ditched a handgun that was later found by a 9-year-old boy.

      Police say the circumstances surrounding the arrest have been investigated and found to be within policy.

Published Wednesday, April 09, 2008 2:41 PM by Kiyoshi Tomono

Comments

 

catpaw said:

I'm glad to know that a violent criminal is off the streets for a few years--well, maybe two years, when the early release policy is considered. Is his sentence subject to 3 Strikes?

Just curious. What happened to the recording of the melee? Who owns the "movie" now?  
April 10, 2008 9:56 AM
 

Kiyoshi Tomono said:

catpaw---the originial, I believe,is still being held in evidence at the courthouse.   The video provided to us was a copy of that. The BPD has its own copy as well.  We did post the video in its entirety on our Website: you can find it on the same page as the story.  Sgt. Greg Terry said this is the entire tape: it's the same thing that the BPD has, no more, no less.

As for Marella, I don't think this is his 3rd strike.
April 10, 2008 2:23 PM
 

CALLMEMSTRACY said:

CATPAW:  Leonard Marella was the wrong suspect in the home invasion robbery; he did not have anything to do with that.  Mr. Marella is not a violent criminal, but he does have a drug problem and, although Mr. Marella was not right for running from police, the Bakersfield Police Department was wrong for the physical abuse they did on him.  Keep in mind that a person is considered innocent until proven guilty in a court of law and just because the police say it does not mean it is true or accurate.  Police are not always the good guys; there are good cops and bad cops and Bakersfied has it's share of bad cops.
April 13, 2008 7:14 AM
 

catpaw said:

As I recall the news report, a gun Mr. Marella was carrying was recovered. I did not see brutality on the tape. The suspect was resisting arrest, the dog was restrained, he was not being beaten. I understand Mr. Marella admitted he ran from the police because he has an outstanding warrant for his arrest.

The tape plainly shows an officer telling Mr. Zamora to step back. He didn't.

If an ex-felon carrying a gun is nonviolent, I hope I don't run into a violent one.
April 15, 2008 11:34 AM
 

CALLMEMSTRACY said:

Mr. Marella had no business carrying a gun, but he was using it for his own personal protection.  I in no way approve of the gun part, but he had no plan on using it on anyone unless he had to.  Police knew nothing of the gun when they physically abused Mr. Marella because police searched the area and found nothing that day; the gun was found he next day in someones back yard.  The reason Mr. Marella had the gun was because he was using it to protect himself because he had a lot of dope on him.  Again, I am not making excuses for the wrong he did, but the police were also wrong in how thy handled the arrest.  Initially, police thought Mr. Marella was someone else, but they later found out they had the wrong man.  I think the video clearly shows Mr. Xavier Zamora stepping back when the officer told him to.
April 29, 2008 3:35 AM
 

tfaulk13 said:

What i recall seeing was Mr. Zamora stepping back when first directed, but then he moved closer to the altercation with the police and Mr. Marella. As for the comment that Mr. Marella had the gun for the purpose of his own protection because he had a lot dope on him and had no plan of using it on anyone unless he had to...WOW! The police may have mistaken him for a robbery suspect, but he ran. Seriously think from an officers point of view for a moment. You have report of an elderly man beaten and robbed of a gun and whatever else by a cowardly worthless individual. While canvassing to find the individual, they come across an individual that takes off running at the sight of the police officers. They don't have the ability to know if this is the person that commited the robbery or is someone running for another reason. What kind of chances should they take with the known and unknown info they have? Apparently Mr. Marella tossed his gun while the pursuit was going on. Even if he didn't, are the police expected to know which criminals with a gun will use it to shoot them and which one's won't? Then, whether he had his hands up and ready to surrender or not, until he is down, cuffed and under control he is a threat to the officers and general public or at a minimum is at risk of bolting away again. If Mr. Marella had simply produced his hands for the officers to cuff him, he never would've been tasered. you cannot claim that he complied, because the officers would've definately put cuffs on if able to. They had no knowledge of why he was not complying, but can't be expected to allow an individual to pull a weapon out if they have one. Yes, we are all innocent until proven guilty. Here's some info you may not know...It is against the law to run or drive away from a law enforcement officer, even if you've done absolutely nothing wrong prior to "bolting away". It's the act of fleeing just at the sight of a police officer that is a violation of California law. Another eye opener...There have been many cases of people that everyone who knows them swears they would never use a gun or act violently without provocation. Yet while prolonged drug use takes it's toll on the individual, they are often arrested for acts of violence or murder. After being arrested and their system becomes drug free for awhile, they almost always say they're sorry and they just weren't in control of their actions anymore...it was because of the drugs.
September 12, 2008 1:54 AM
Anonymous comments are disabled

About Kiyoshi Tomono

Kiyoshi Tomono joined the 17 News team in March of 2004. He currently anchors 17 News at Sunrise and reports for other newscasts. Kiyoshi has won two Golden Mike Awards and an Associated Press Mark Twain award for his investigative and feature reporting. He is also the recipient of the 2008 RTNDA Edward R. Murrow Award for investigating reporting on Crisp and Cole Real Estate that ended in an FBI raid of the company

This Blog

Post Calendar

<April 2008>
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
303112345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
27282930123
45678910

Syndication

Inergize Digital Media This site powered by Inergize Digital Media. The views expressed here do not necessarily reflect the views of this station.