KGET Community

Welcome to KGET Community Sign in | Join | Help
in
back to KGET.com Home Blogs Forums Photos Calendar

Kiyoshi Tomono's Blog

Posting Firefighter's Salaries: Invasion of Privacy or Right-To-Know 10/2/07

Kern County firefighters have dangerous, difficult jobs.

They're required to work around the clock under the worst conditions nature can throw at them. It's a job that can kill you in a heartbeat. It's a job most people couldn't do.

But.... for putting their lives on the line, the county pays its firefighters pretty well.

Fire captains make about $78,000 a year.

Engineers make about $60,000.

Firefighters, the basic rank among first responders in the department, make about $45,000.

And hundreds of kern county fire department personnel supplement their incomes by tens of thousands of dollars each from an overtime budget that is half the size of the regular payroll.

That's the finding in a 17 News examination of records recently made public by a landmark court case.  It's a court case fought by the Bakersfield Californian.

In 2005 ... 21 employees made more than 50-thousand dollars in overtime. Nearly 300 made more than 20-thousand in OT.

Of the 865 people on the payroll that year ... 124 made more than 100-thousand in 2005

Year-to-date figures for 2007 show that figure going up.

As of september 11th ... with 913 people on the payroll ... 22 employees had made more than 50-thousand dollars in overtime ... about the same as in all of 2005.

And there are 29 others who have made more than 40-thousand in ot ... putting them on course to finish 2007 with 50-thousand or more.in overtime for the year. .

But both 2005 and 2006 pale in comparison to 2006, when crews battled the massive day fire near the grapevine.

In 2006 fifty-eight 58 KCFD employees made more than 50-thousand dollars in overtime.

Dozens made more than 60-thousand dollars in OT. Several made 70- .... 80 .... and 90-thousand dollars in overtime alone. One man, an engineer with a base salary of $66,000, earned $103,000 in overtime in 2006.

Add that to the 87-thousand in overtime he made in 2005 and the 80-thousand in ot so far this year and he's made a total of 460-thousand in the last three years.

The caveat here is the the fire department says much of the overtime is due to those big state fires that require the help of fire agencies from a multitude of counties.  And we're told the money is repaid to the state.  Seeing as though it's neither feasbile nor cost-effective to have a statewide task force on standby for those big fires, the county says this is the most efficient use of taxpayer money.

All of the salary information was provided to us on disk, as required by law. That means we can post the salary information here for you to browse.  It's a basic Excel spreadsheet with the employee's name, job classification, and pay.

What do you think?  Is this an invasion of prviacy or the public's right to know?  Do YOU want to see the records posted here?

Published Tuesday, October 02, 2007 2:35 PM by Kiyoshi Tomono

Comments

 

Kiyoshi Tomono said:

From a grateful citizen:

The engineer you featured in your story about public
employees' salaries made a lot of money that was
funded by taxes, and the public concern is
understandable.  But there are three things making
that engineer deserving of that salary.  First, he
payed taxes on all that money and I can almost
guarantee he payed more than most of the citizens of Bakersfield or Kern County.  Second, he has earned that position by completing numerous hours of training, and even more hours actually on duty - protecting us.  Third, has anyone considered the number of lives saved by our firefighters?  Ask some of those people if firefighters are over paid.  Anyone who has not had to call 9-1-1 in a panic while a loved one is close to losing their life shouldn't complain about pay; they should instead spend that time being thankful for the health they enjoy at this point in their life.
October 2, 2007 7:29 PM
 

Kiyoshi Tomono said:

From Rob:

They risk their lives for us who cares how much they make!!
October 2, 2007 7:29 PM
 

Kiyoshi Tomono said:

From Butch:
YES, WE AS TAX PAYORS SHOULD KNOW WHAT THEIR SALARIES ARE. WE’RE THE ONES PAYING THAT SALARY.
October 2, 2007 7:29 PM
 

Kiyoshi Tomono said:

From Philip
if your going to post firefighter salaries then you shopuld post all salaries paid by the tax payer including elected officials with all the perks including what they retire with that no one else gets
October 2, 2007 7:33 PM
 

Greg83 said:

The Engineer featured on the news tonight made that salary by spending as much time working overtime as he did his normal shift work.  Firefighters work 10 days a month with no overtime, he was working 20+ a month.  That's two thirds of his or her life spent away from home.  It's cheaper for the taxpayers to pay overtime rather than hire more firefighters.  The dedication firefighters put in to their work is amazing.  They are working two jobs because some bean counter somewhere figured out it was cheaper to make an individual work more rather than hire more people for the position vacant.  Who cares if one person gets a large check, he or she is picking up the slack for the people in the job that don't want the overtime.  The fire department never closes and they are not allowed to strike, the position must be filled.  There are times in the fire department when an individual is ordered to stay at work to fill a vacancy.  Have you ever been ready to get off work after working with no sleep for 24 hours and been told "No sorry, you are going to be staying another 24 hours."?  Blue colar job or not, these people are playing iron-man football and protecting our lives on a daily basis.  I could care less what they make as long as they are there for me when I need them.
October 2, 2007 8:19 PM
 

AlleyM said:

I'll be upfront, my husband is a county firefighter.  I think a better way to do this story would have been to find the cost of manning all of the county stations without overtime including the cost of benefits and then compare that with the current amount being paid minus the amounts repaid to the county by the state and federal governments.   Just would like to see some honest thought put into the stories to make them factual reports.
October 3, 2007 10:40 AM
 

creepykat said:

AlleyM does make a point. I think taxpayers have a right to know where their money is going but it shouldn't be reported as employees raking in $100K without some kind of contrast or qualification.
Reporting the salary of a firefighter is one thing; reporting salaries of individuals is an invasion of privacy. How much an individual makes is a matter between him and the IRS.
October 3, 2007 12:40 PM
 

Kiyoshi Tomono said:

AlleyM,
Can't figure where we failed to be factual.   But yes, prospective here is key.  That's why we mentioned the state reimbursement for large, statewide incidents.  We did ask to take a look at those budget numbers (i.e overtime, state reimbursement)when we aired the story Tuesday, but the department declined, saying they would release them during the news conference Thursday instead.
-K
October 4, 2007 10:38 AM
Anonymous comments are disabled

About Kiyoshi Tomono

Kiyoshi Tomono joined the 17 News team in March of 2004. He currently anchors 17 News at Sunrise and reports for other newscasts. Kiyoshi has won two Golden Mike Awards and an Associated Press Mark Twain award for his investigative and feature reporting. He is also the recipient of the 2008 RTNDA Edward R. Murrow Award for investigating reporting on Crisp and Cole Real Estate that ended in an FBI raid of the company

This Blog

Post Calendar

<October 2007>
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
30123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031123
45678910

Syndication

Inergize Digital Media This site powered by Inergize Digital Media. The views expressed here do not necessarily reflect the views of this station.